Key takeaways
- Mortgage underwriting these days is an automated process – software decides whether you are approved, rejected, or asked for additional information.
- Credit score is the most important factor in determining mortgage approval, but your income and debt levels, as well as the size of the loan vs. the home’s value, are also major factors.
- Recent changes in your financial stability, such as a new job or unusual bank account activity, can delay mortgage approval.
For borrowers in a still-hot housing market, getting approved for a mortgage can be a challenge. Mortgage rates have soared from pandemic-era lows, home values are near record highs and home price appreciation is outpacing wage growth.
All of that means there’s no guarantee a lender will approve your mortgage application. Here’s a look at how lenders decide to extend credit, and some common obstacles borrowers face.
How does mortgage underwriting work?
Mortgage underwriting is the process of verifying and analyzing the financial information you provide your lender – all with the goal of giving you an answer of yes, no or maybe. As part of the application, you produce bank statements, W-2s and other tax documents, recent pay stubs and any additional documentation the lender requires or requests.
Dispense with any stereotypes about the old days of lending or the movie It’s A Wonderful Life, when a banker determined your creditworthiness by the firmness of your handshake and the crispness of your shirt. In most cases, a loan officer or mortgage broker will collect your information and submit it to an underwriting software system – Desktop Underwriter for a loan that will be sold to Fannie Mae, Loan Product Advisor for Freddie Mac.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are government-sponsored enterprises that make a market in mortgages: Between them, they buy or back about two-thirds of all U.S. home loans.
These systems don’t allow for much in the way of human judgment – the software determines whether you’re either approved, rejected or asked for additional information. Such automated underwriting, as it’s officially called, is the norm nowadays — part of the reforms to the mortgage financing world developed after the 2007-09 mortgage meltdown and subsequent financial crisis. “Prior to the crisis, there was more leeway,” says Bill Banfield, chief risk officer at Rocket Mortgage. “Now, most of that subjectivity is gone.”
There are many reasons – income, or property type, or something else – that the automated underwriting process might flag your application. And if it does, there’s little the human loan officers can do about it.
Keep in mind: The main thing the lender decides is your mortgage’s interest rate. And of course, how much to charge you in fees.
Reasons a mortgage loan is denied
“There’s a thousand potential questions Fannie [or Freddie] could return,” says David Aach,chief operating officer at Blue Sage Solutions, a mortgage technology firm. “That’s the nightmare of the underwriting process.” Here are some of the more common reasons you might not get approved for a mortgage.
1. You have credit issues
Your credit score is the single most important factor in determining your mortgage rate – and whether you get approved at all. Generally, the best deals go to borrowers with credit scores of 740 or above, and ones in the “good” range — 670 to 739 — are the most desirable.
Still, you can qualify for some types of mortgages with much lower scores. For instance, VA loans generally are available to borrowers with scores of 620 or above, white FHA loans go to those with scores as low as 580.
Before applying for a mortgage, check your credit score and credit report and dispute any errors. If your credit score is low, work on boosting it before you apply (for example, you could ask a card company to increase your credit line, which automatically lowers your credit utilization ratio). If you have a qualifying credit score, make sure you don’t do anything during the mortgage process to cause it to drop, like miss a payment or max out a credit card, or apply for some other big new loan.
If you don’t have a credit score at all, some lenders do have alternative credit scoring methods, such as analyzing your bank deposits. In fact, last year Fannie Mae updated Desktop Underwriter to take into account a loan applicant’s financial and investment accounts, as an alternative to an absent credit score or incomplete credit history.
2. You have an income shortfall
Your debt-to-income (DTI) ratio — the portion of your gross (pre-tax) monthly income spent on repaying regular obligations — signals to lenders whether you’re in a position to take on an additional, major debt. If your DTI is too high, you may be rejected for a mortgage. Most lenders require a DTI of less than 43 percent, with 50 percent the max.
Aim for your obligations comprising about one-third of your income: A DTI around 36 percent is the ideal, qualifying you for better loan terms. If you owe a lot in student loans, car loans or credit card balances, work on bringing those balances down before applying for a mortgage.
Also give a thought to the type of loan: The longer its term, the more affordable its monthly payments. So opting for a 30-year mortgage might boost your chances, even though you’ll pay more in interest over its lifespan, compared to shorter-term loans.
On the income side, issues often emerge when the mortgage applicant is self-employed. In the first place, the software is geared to good old W-2s — that wage-and-tax-statement from an employer — and gets uneasy when an income stream is irregular, even if your earnings are high.
Also, business owners often maximize write-offs and expenses when doing their taxes – but that common practice flummoxes the underwriting models.“Self-employed people know what they make, but they don’t know what an underwriter is looking for,” says Tom Hutchens, executive vice president at Angel Oak, a lender specializing in non-QM loans (mortgages outside the conventional criteria). “They might be fully approved, but then an underwriter looks at the tax returns” and sees that “$10,000 a month might become $5,000 a month in income.” The lower amount upsets the software, which then dings the applicant.
3. The loan-to-value ratio (LTV) is too high
Lenders also look at how much of a mortgage you want, vis-à-vis the value of the home you’re buying — something called the loan-to-value ratio (LTV). The bigger your down payment, the less you borrow, and the lower your LTV. For instance, if you’re buying a $400,000 house with a down payment of $80,000, your LTV is a comfortable 80 percent. (While there’s no single perfect percentage, lenders usually like to see it around this amount — for conventional loans, anyway.) But if you’re putting down $20,000, the LTV is up to 95 percent.
The higher your LTV, the more likelihood that your loan will be flagged for follow-up questions, or rejected altogether. If you feel you need help lowering your LTV, look into down payment assistance – every state has these programs, especially for first-time buyers — to increase the amount of cash you can bring to the deal.
4. You’re trying to finance an out-of-favor property
Not all homes are created equal, as far as lenders are concerned. The traditional, detached single-family residence still rules, and alternatives can confound.
Condos are one particularly tough type of home to finance. In response to the June 2021 collapse of an oceanfront tower near Miami, Fannie and Freddie rolled out new rules covering condo loans: The giant mortgage market-makers have decided not to finance some buildings that have low reserves, need repairs, or are facing lawsuits. Critics say the stricter reviews are causing condo sales to fall apart, even in buildings with no structural issues.
Manufactured homes also can be challenging to finance. And if appraisers or inspectors find a structural flaw or other issue with the home itself, that also can slow the approval, or even kill it.
5. Something recently changed in your financial life
The lending process prizes financial stability and predictability(remember what we said about income, above). And while the job market was still going strong as of early 2024, many Americans have changed positions, either by choice or by necessity. Unfortunately, a recent job change or period of unemployment can throw a wrench in your approval. A short employment history or interruption in earnings sends warning signals to the software.
Unusual activity in your bank account can be another issue. Underwriters are skittish about large, unusual deposits, which might mean you borrowed money for your down payment. If you got money from relatives to help you buy a house, make sure to submit a gift letter as part of your application.
How to get a mortgage after your application is denied
Take heart:If you are denied a mortgage, all is not lost. There are workarounds to many of these issues.
If you have a unique income situation, such as owning a business with unsteady cash flow, you might apply for a non-QM mortgage. These loans come with more flexible credit criteria and income requirements than conventional loans, making them ideal for those who don’t fit the standard borrower box.
If your credit score or LTV was the problem, you can also consider loans through the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) and Veterans Administration (VA). Their terms are more generous, geared toward borrowers with lower credit scores or little cash for down payments.
Manual underwriting
The vast majority of conforming loans – those eligible to be bought by Fannie and Freddie – are decided via automatic underwriting. It’s fast, cheap and takes bias out of the process. But some loans still are reviewed by a human. Lenders often do manual underwriting when an application would likely be denied through an automated system, or if the borrower has some unusual circ*mstances but is otherwise qualified.
Certain types of mortgages, like jumbo loans and non-QM loans, are more likely to be manually underwritten. But you can request it for any mortgage, if you believe your particular situation will not be fully understood by the ‘bot. Be prepared to supply additional paperwork — financial statements reaching farther back, for example — and for a longer process. Bear in mind that, even with a manual underwriter, your loan still has to conform to specific requirements.
Bottom line
The mortgage application process can be full of surprises — with a key one being that an automated underwriting system often decides your approval or denial. The key reasons for rejection often involve credit score issues, income shortfalls, high loan-to-value ratios, property type, or recent changes in your financial situation. But the ‘bot doesn’t necessarily have to have the last word. Find out why your application was denied, and then seek remedies: explore alternatives to conventional conforming loans, or request manual underwriting (a review by a human underwriter). Any of these may provide a pathway to homeownership.
