Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop ? (2024)

Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop  (1)

Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop  (2)

Summary

The first FDA-approved tubeless, waterproof pump that can be controlled entirely from a compatible Android smartphone. The system combines the Omnipod patch pump with the Dexcom continuous glucose monitor (CGM) to automatically adjust insulin delivery in response to glucose trends.

Tidepool Loop is thefirst fully interoperableautomated insulin dosing appthat originated as a patient-led initiative.

Background: A diabetes non-profit called Tidepool decided in 2018 to officially support Loop and shepherd it through the FDA process. Tidepool Loop was cleared by the FDA in January 2023 with plans to launch with Dexcom and other alternate controller-enabled (ACE) pump partners (RileyLink will no longer be necessary).

2023 Updates from Tidepool:

  • Medtronic and Tidepool have decided to discontinue the development of a Medtronic insulin pump system compatible with Tidepool Loop.
  • As Omnipod 5 is now commercially available, Insulet is devoting all available resources to their Omnipod products, including the global launch and further development of Omnipod 5.
  • Future ACE Pumps that will be commercially compatible with Tidepool Loop will need to be FDA-cleared for usewith third-partyinteroperable automated glycemic (iAGC) controllers.

Components

Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop  (3)

Omnipod 5 : Pump

Pods come with reservoirs and directions for application. They can be applied anywhere on the body that is comfortable.

Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop  (4)

Omnipod 5 : Sensor

Automatic applicator inserts sensor just under the surface of the skin and can be applied to many places on the body.

Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop  (5)

Omnipod 5 : Controller

Smartphone receives CGM readings to automatically adjust basal insulin delivery via a tubeless pod. All insulin delivery can be fully controlled on the OmniPod app via a compatible Android smartphone.

Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop  (6)

Tidepool Loop : Controller

Smartphone or smartwatch receives CGM readings and automatically adjusts insulin delivery via insulin pump.

Device Details

Affordability and Access

$$$$
Widely covered for insulin-dependenttype 1 and 2. Supplies for Pump and Sensor provided by Pharmacy and/or DME suppliers. Projected price range; $5-$1260 to start and 0-$200/month.

$$$$
Pump and CGM supply information is not yet available. iPhone is not covered and must be set up independently.

Data Monitoring Options

Yes
Dexcom Clarity provides multiple data views and access through theCLARITY ClinicianPortalOmnipod data can be accessed by clinicians onDiasend by Glooko.

Yes
Compatible withTidepool- aweb-based diabetes data management system.

Data View Options

Yes
Dexcom sensors permit remote monitoring. The Omnipod DISPLAY app displays real-time data for the patient. The Omnipod VIEW app allows family and friends to view datafor up to 12 Omnipod users.(iPhone compatible only).

Yes
Data can be viewed on an iPhone.

Duration and Storage

3-day pump 10-day sensor
Sensors last 10 days and transmitters last 90 and work at 50ºF –108ºF. Pods can be used for up to 72 hrs and work from 41ºF –104ºF.

Pump and CGM information not yet available.

Vision / Auditory / Dexterity

NOtext to speech
YESvibration alerts
A LOTofdexterity needed

NOtext to speech
YES
vibration alerts
A LOT
ofdexterity needed

Patient Considerations

Active Lifestyle

Exercise mode and waterproof. Can manually increase target to 150 mg/dl and suspend insulin delivery during exercise. Fully waterproof, tubeless, and can be worn for most exercises.

Automatic responses. Can set custom blood sugar targets and insulin and carb sensitivities based on type of activity. App automatically responds to blood sugar changes during activity.

Avoiding Highs and Lows

Auto-basal featureadjusts insulin delivery every 5-minutes based onDexcom CGM trends to maintain a target blood glucose between 110 mg/dl and 150 mg/dl. This system does not give auto-bolus correction.

Automatically adjusts insulin delivery. Increases or decreases insulin delivery to meet glucose targets. Insulin delivery settings can be aggressive or conservative.

Comfort

Low profile & no tubing.Low profile sensor and Omnipod has no tubing but may require more adhesive on the body than other pumps.

Low-profile mobile app. Dosing and other adjustments can be done directly on the mobile app.

Easy Insulin Dosing

Automatically adjusts dosing.Sensor trends feed into Pods' customizable dose adjustments and there are no interruptions in insulin delivery. Basaland bolus in 0.05 increments. Extended bolus unavailable when using automated insulin delivery mode.

Customizable. Can bolus from phone or smartwatch and all settings are expected to be customizable. More information onmodifications to insulin delivery will be available soon.

Easy to Use

Fewer components.Pod has fewer components to deal with than other pumps.

Easy dosing. Software makes most dosing decisions easy to do on the fly.

Fewer Fingersticks

Factory-calibrated sensor.Fingersticks needed for backup only.

Factory-calibrated sensor. Fingersticks needed for backup only.

Privacy

Discreet. Sensor allows for checking blood glucose on phone/smartwatch. Most discreet pump option with no visible controller required if using an Android smartphone.

Discreet. Ability to give insulin via watch or phone.Ability to check sugar on phone or watch. Alerts available.

Device Finder - Omnipod 5 vs Tidepool Loop  ? (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Velia Krajcik

Last Updated:

Views: 5557

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Velia Krajcik

Birthday: 1996-07-27

Address: 520 Balistreri Mount, South Armand, OR 60528

Phone: +466880739437

Job: Future Retail Associate

Hobby: Polo, Scouting, Worldbuilding, Cosplaying, Photography, Rowing, Nordic skating

Introduction: My name is Velia Krajcik, I am a handsome, clean, lucky, gleaming, magnificent, proud, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.